When a person’s Australian visa is at risk due to character concerns, Ministerial Direction 110 (MD110) plays a crucial role in the decision-making process. This official guideline tells visa decision-makers how to balance public safety, individual rights, and Australia’s immigration policies when assessing character-related visa cancellations or refusals.
In this blog, we break down what Direction 110 means, its primary and secondary considerations, and how it affects the outcomes of character visa cancellations.
What Is Ministerial Direction 110?
Ministerial Direction 110 is a binding legal instrument issued under section 499 of the Migration Act 1958. It provides structured guidance for the Department of Home Affairs when considering whether to refuse or cancel a visa on character grounds, especially under section 501 of the Act.
This Direction replaced the earlier Direction 90 in early 2023 and sets out a clear hierarchy of considerations, primary and other (secondary), that must be weighed before a visa decision is made.
Primary Considerations Under Direction 110
MD110 identifies five primary considerations that carry the most weight in character decisions:
1. Protection of the Australian Community
Public safety is the top priority. If the visa holder has engaged in criminal conduct or poses a future risk of harm to the community, this weighs heavily in favour of cancellation. This includes both physical violence and serious non-violent offences.
2. Family Violence
Any history of family or domestic violence is treated as a serious breach of character expectations. This includes abuse against partners, children, or other household members, whether or not criminal charges were laid.
3. Ties to Australia
The decision-maker must consider the person’s connection to Australia, such as length of residence, citizen family members, employment history, and community integration. For long-term residents, especially those who arrived as children, this factor can significantly mitigate against cancellation.
4. Best Interests of Minor Children in Australia
This factor protects the welfare of children who may be impacted by a visa cancellation. The officer must assess:
- Emotional bonds between the child and the visa holder
- The child’s need for stability and care
- Whether other support arrangements are available
- The likely effect of separation on the child’s well-being
A cancellation can still proceed even if children are affected, but the impact must be properly assessed and justified.
5. Expectations of the Australian Community
This is a unique and powerful consideration. It is based not on public surveys, but on the government’s stated assumptions about public standards. MD110 directs officials to presume that Australians expect non-citizens to follow the law and that serious offending will not be tolerated.
In fact, community expectations alone may justify cancellation, even if other factors suggest the person should be allowed to stay.
Other (Secondary) Considerations
In addition to the primary factors, Direction 110 outlines “other considerations” that must also be evaluated, though they carry less weight. These include:
- International non-refoulement obligations
- Impact on Australian business or cultural interests
- Impact on victims or the broader community
- Health, mental health, or other personal hardship
These secondary factors are not ignored but must be balanced against the stronger weight of the five primary considerations.
How Direction 110 Is Applied in Practice
Under Direction 110, decision-makers are not allowed to make personal judgments about public opinion or moral character. Instead, they must follow the government’s prescribed interpretation of community values and weigh each factor explicitly.
Even if a person has lived in Australia for decades and has children here, their visa may still be cancelled if the conduct involved is serious and the community is deemed to expect removal. Conversely, if the conduct is less serious and there are strong humanitarian or child-related factors, the visa may be retained.
Conclusion
Direction 110 fundamentally shapes the way Australia handles character-based visa cancellations and refusals. It reinforces the principle that community safety comes first, while still requiring a fair and structured assessment of individual circumstances.
If you or someone you know is facing a character cancellation under section 501, understanding how Direction 110 operates is essential, and professional legal advice is strongly recommended.
Need Help With a Character Cancellation Case?
Our migration law team can assist you with preparing submissions, gathering supporting evidence, and representing you at the ART or in Ministerial Intervention matters. Contact us today for a confidential consultation.
📞 (03) 9125 8820
✉️ info@aurelialegal.com.au
🌐 www.aurelialegal.com.au
Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Visa criteria, policy, and processing times are subject to change. Please consult a registered migration agent or legal practitioner for advice specific to your situation.